![]() |
| Can't walk, won't walk |
Their BB% was the joint lowest in the MLB with the Baltimore Orioles at 6.9. But if Barnett starts asking his hitters to be more patient, then will that have a knock on effect towards their hitting. With guys like Carlos Lee, they are far too stuck in their ways to change their plate discipline without changing their entire approach in the batters' box.
Lee, Pence, and come to think of it Johnson are free-swingers. That is their strength. Here is the BB% tabulation for the Astros expected 2011 lineup:
Hitters | BB% (career) | BB% (2010) |
Carlos Lee | 7.2 | 5.7 |
Michael Bourn | 8.9 | 9.8 |
Chris Johnson | 4.1 | |
Jason Castro | 10.1 | |
Hunter Pence | 6.8 | 6.2 |
Brett Wallace | 5.0 | |
Clint Barmes | 5.0 | 8.1 |
Bill Hall | 7.8 | 8.9 |
On the face of it, Hall and Barmes look like promising additions to the lineup. Their BB%s are decent enough, but both numbers should come with a warning. First Barmes. For the majority of 2010 he hit in the number 8 slot in the Rockies lineup, basically meaning pitchers didn't have to throw him anything decent over the middle of the plate with the pitcher on deck. Maybe that affected his power numbers too, as his ISO dropped from .195 in 2009 to .116 last year.
Hall batted 7th, 8th and 9th for the Red Sox, but be warned, his K% is horrendous, hovering around the 30% mark.
So the lineup will lack a big bopper, something it has had for years, and will have to work as a single unit to score runs. This may work well, or it may all break down and in that case we will be stuffed. Lineup construction. Good luck with that Brad Mills. The lazy option might be to put Pence at 3 and Lee at 4, but depending on how Hall looks in spring, I might be tempted to put him at 3, start Barmes at 2 with Castro at 9, swapping the two if Castro starts the season well.
Also I wonder how much help Mike Barnett is asking for from Milt Thompson, the former Phillies hitting coach, and now the Astros' baserunning and outfield coordinator in the Astros' minor leagues.


